ESPN just posted this article dissecting the MVPs of the rivalry since 1995 — the year both teams made the playoffs.
I won’t go into details here, but here are the MVPs of both teams — the lineup and the rotation.
Red Sox MVP: Manny Ramirez (no surprise here, this was to be expected)
Red Sox MVP pitcher: Pedro Martinez (I may have thought of Curt Schilling, but Pedro was around longer than Curt and he had several gems, even if he was the Yankees’ “Daddy.”)
Yankees MVP: Alex Rodriguez (I think what surprises me the most is that Paul O’Neill is second on the list and Jeter isn’t even in the top five)
Yankees MVP pitcher: Mariano Rivera (No surprises here, and number two is Andy Pettitte, again no surprises here.
I think it’s quite an interesting article to read, so go ahead and click on the link above to read about the MVPs of the rivalry.